Data As An Asset Part 1 – Should Data be on your Balance Sheet?

You often hear people say “Information is our greatest asset”. If that’s true, why can’t we find “data” assets on the financial balance sheet? Some organizations do indeed capitalize IT investments, but primarily in order to spread the costs over a number of years and not because they are valuing their data assets. Occasionally you might find data on the balance sheet such as the customer lists valued at $14.5B on AT&T’s 2007 financial statements – but again this was a one-time event related to the acquisition of Bell South and not because AT&T systematically values their data.

But, so what. Is it a problem that companies don’t formally value data assets? Yes – because it takes much more than financial assets for companies to generate shareholder value in today’s economy. For evidence you need only look at the ratio of book value to market value of various firms; some firms have a high stock price relative to the value of assets while other firms in the same industry have a low relative stock price. The difference is a result of intangible assets such as a strong management team, innovative employees that produce breakthrough improvements, and proprietary information that no-one else has. By some estimates, intangible assets account for more than 50% of the value of the firm yet they are not represented on the balance sheet.

Furthermore, if data is not an asset, then it is treated as a cost. Since the natural reaction of business is to minimize costs, IT organizations are treated like cost centers with continuous pressures to reduce expenditures rather than looking for ways to increase the value and bottom-line earnings of the assets. Examples of valuable information assets include product research data, manufacturing cost data, geological data for energy reserves, and customer relationship, risk, and behavior models. Yet if this data is treated simply as a cost from a management perspective, it will not receive the appropriate level of attention from an investment perspective and will remain under-leveraged.

Judy Ko gets the credit for starting this discussion in her recent blog, Managing Data As An Asset - Walking The Walk, where she discusses some of the more practical aspects of treating data as an asset. I am picking up this train of thought with a series of blog postings planned for the next few months. The topics I have in mind at the moment include:

  • Should data be on your balance sheet? (this post)
  • Valuing data using managerial accounting practices
  • A market-based approach to valuing data
  • Case study in managing data assets
  • Data can be an asset – it can also be a liability
  • The future: Agile Data-Driven enterprises

From an accounting perspective, assets are economic resources owned by a firm. Assets have a value that generally can be turned into cash (although cash itself is also an asset and some assets may be less liquid and harder to convert to cash). The balance sheet of a firm records the monetary value of the assets it owns. Two major asset classes are tangible assets and intangible assets. Tangible assets contain various subclasses, including current assets such as inventory and fixed assets such as buildings and equipment. Intangible assets are nonphysical resources and have a value to the firm because they give it some kind of advantage in the market place. Examples of intangible assets are copyrights, trademarks, patents, and computer programs.

Formally putting data on your balance sheet is a big decision and I for one would not recommend it until you have first established the internal organizational disciplines for managing and valuing data as assets.  I will turn to this topic in my next post – Valuing data using managerial accounting practices.

This entry was posted in Business Impact / Benefits, CIO, Data Governance, Enterprise Data Management, Governance, Risk and Compliance, Integration Competency Centers, Master Data Management and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Data As An Asset Part 1 – Should Data be on your Balance Sheet?

  1. Pingback: Data As An Asset Part 1 – Should Data be on your Balance Sheet … | Suporte de Informática

  2. Sachin Khairnar says:

    thanks for initiating this. I hope industry standards like GAAP / IFRS will begin to add data asset valuation apart from regulations asking for trusted data.

    And, in my opinion, this is where Enterprise Data/information management disciplines could help make it happen
    - Data governance to establish policies and decision rights to manage data as an asset
    - Data quality to measure/highlight the value
    - MDM & integration to spread the value
    - BI/EPM to analyze and utilize the value
    - Making it all real from abstract concepts for business leaders.

    My recent article, on valuing data from operating cost perspective, was published in lead stories on IM magazine.


    - Sachin

  3. Gary Fish says:

    Yes – Data and Information should be carried on the BS as Capital Asset – I’ve been fighting this battle for 30 years. John I’m really pleased that this has been on the table for discussion, Mark Albala should be a contributor as well…

  4. John Schmidt says:

    Gary and Sachin, thanks for your input and suggestions. I’ve also received input through LinkedIn and Twitter networks which is very encouraging. Based on the strong interest, I’ll keep the blog series going.

  5. Doug Laney says:

    John et al, I have been researching and consulting on the topic of information asset valuation for about ten years (since my days as a META Group research director). While there are no formally accepted valuation models, I have developed some that can be readily put into practice. Some consider information’s relative intrinsic value, others consider it’s replacement/loss value and others it’s measured business and economic value.

    I will be teaching a course on information asset management and valuation at the upcoming TDWI World Conference in Orlando Nov 7 ( http://1l2.us/bzz ). I also recently did a hour-long radio interview on the topic ( http://1l2.us/bBy ). And a article in the BI Journal is due out next month.

    Feel free to reach me directly for more…er…info. Cheers, Doug

  6. My developer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on a variety of websites for about a year and am nervous about switching to another platform. I have heard great things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  7. executive says:

    Hello there, magnificent internet site. All of the ideas you created on have been really helpful. I tried to include in your Feed to my own news reader. Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>